Home / Pros and cons of living in an NYC Brownstone

Pros and cons of living in an NYC Brownstone

Get Matched with the Best Moving Companies in NYC

Moving From

Moving To

Tell us just a little bit more about your move:

Please insert your contact details and we will get back to you with an estimated price and the best match for your move:

By clicking the “get estimate” button above I agree to the terms of service and the privacy policy. I also verify that this is my telephone number and give consent to representatives of Best Movers NYC and its moving company partners to contact me via email, text message, or by phone. I understand that my consent is not a requirement for any purchase. I understand I may withdraw my consent at any time. Message and data rates may apply.

New York City holds unique architecture at its heart. Its skyline narrates tales of Gothic Revival, Beaux-Arts, and Art Deco styles. Amid these giants, a humble star shines – the iconic brownstone homes. Their rustic charm and enduring legacy remain quintessential to the Big Apple’s architecture. Living in an NYC brownstone is a one-of-a-kind experience that you will soon learn more about. With that in mind, in this text, Best Movers NYC pulls back the curtain on these brick-and-mortar masterpieces, highlighting both the pros and cons of residing in them.

The brownstones have a characteristic charm to them

NYC’s brownstone buildings began emerging in the 19th century. Crafted primarily from brown Triassic-Jurassic sandstone, this wave of construction altered the city’s architectural panorama. These types of homes can primarily be seen in neighborhoods like Brooklyn Heights or Park Slope. Although, in the 1880s, nearly three-quarters of Brooklyn’s structures bore this style! Today, living in an NYC brownstone is synonymous with a unique charm and historical value.

The allure of these residents lies in the architectural style itself. Detailed carvings, high ceilings, and elaborate front stoops lend an air of old-fashioned elegance. From an exterior bathed in warm brown hues to a rich interior laced with Victorian-era aesthetics, brownstones echo timeless beauty.

Picture of a brownstone building — In the past, three-quarters of Brooklyn was brownstone buildings.

Living in an NYC brownstone comes with a premium price tag

The trusted residential movers NYC boasts have relocated their fair share of folks to these architectural marvels. What they have noticed, however, is that living in one comes with a specific price tag. Current statistics reveal a median brownstone home price ranging from $3 to $10 million. If you want to rent instead, prepare for an average monthly expense of $3,500. Therefore, calling a brownstone your home is a serious investment. One that not many can afford to make.

These homes offer numerous benefits

New York City’s brownstones aren’t reserved only for Brooklyn. In fact, they also grace the Upper West Side, framing the cityscape with their characteristic warmth. Interestingly, these locales offer more than just scenic views. Commencing with location, these architectural gems sit at the heart of bustling city life. Proximity to central parks, renowned museums, and chic boutiques make them particularly desirable to live in. For those yearning to enjoy this unique experience, seasoned movers Upper West Side residents have turned to are renowned for smooth transitions into these historic homes.

Now, let’s discuss the spatial grandeur of these buildings. Residents savor the spacious layouts, typical of the style. Generous living spaces and enchanting backyard gardens give each residence an unmatched blend of urban living and private tranquility.

We cannot overlook the potential for customization. Brownstones present an intriguing canvas for homeowners to leave their own imprint. Whether it’s restoring vintage elements or introducing contemporary upgrades, these homes invite a personal touch.

Picture of two kids enjoying their backyard while living in a NYC brownstone — Many benefits come from these buildings.

Location and layout are not the only benefits of living in NYC brownstones

On top of location and layout, brownstones offer an extraordinary sense of community. Historically, these buildings have fostered tight-knit neighborhoods, building bonds among residents. The close proximity of homes encourages friendly interactions, making these areas feel like small towns located within the big city.

Adding to this, brownstones are often historical landmarks. Therefore, homeowners get the unique privilege of living within and preserving a piece of New York’s rich architectural heritage. The city’s historic preservation laws protect these structures, ensuring they retain their charm and value for years to come.

Moreover, brownstone homes offer a peaceful retreat from the city’s relentless pace. Thanks to their solid sandstone construction, these homes effectively insulate against street noise, offering a serene sanctuary in the heart of the bustling metropolis.

In terms of investment, brownstones have shown consistent appreciation over the years. Their timeless appeal, coupled with the finite supply, makes them a sound real estate investment.

Nothing comes without drawbacks

These buildings are magnificent, especially those in the northwestern part of Brooklyn, where our Carroll Gardens movers can get you to. Living in an NYC brownstone, while alluring, does come with specific challenges. But each potential homeowner should weigh these considerations with the myriad of benefits.

To begin with, maintenance costs can be substantial. With their intricate detail work and aging infrastructure, these historic homes may require regular upkeep. Therefore, budgeting for potential structural repairs, plumbing updates, or other maintenance tasks is vital.
Another aspect to ponder is the limited outdoor space. Although some brownstones feature charming backyards, they typically don’t compare to suburban lawn expanses. This might be a concession for families yearning for expansive play areas.
Then, there are noise concerns. Despite their substantial construction, brownstones are usually located in densely populated urban areas. The hustle and bustle of city life can sometimes permeate your serene haven.

Some of the challenges are expected in NYC

Parking difficulties often top the list of challenges. On-street parking is notoriously scarce in densely populated areas where brownstones are prevalent. Securing a spot close to home can feel like a small victory. What’s more, the search for parking becomes a daily routine, or residents resort to paying for private parking options.

Crowded streets are another reality of brownstone living. With their prime location in the city’s heart, these neighborhoods bustle with activity. Busy sidewalks, cycling lanes, and constant traffic become part of the everyday soundscape. While many thrive on this urban energy, it may feel overwhelming to those used to quieter environments.

Lastly, there’s the issue of personal space. Despite the spacious interiors, brownstone living often means closer proximity to your neighbors. With shared walls and tighter outdoor spaces, you might find less privacy than you would in suburban or rural settings.

Picture of a building with stores — Living in an NYC brownstone means living close to busy streets.

NYC brownstones aren’t for everyone, but they sure are alluring!

Evidently, living in an NYC brownstone is not for everybody. With a set of good sides, some bad sides, and a high price, not everyone is meant to love these buildings. But those that do find them appealing and commit to moving to NYC will get to experience the city life firsthand. If that person happens to be you, we sure hope your future brownstone home will be everything you wish for…and more!