When in New York: Staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss

The Big Apple is famous for many tourist attractions, but one thing that interests many is where and what to eat! In this article, we will talk about staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss! We will see what types of food are popular in NYC and how they rose in popularity. As a newcomer to New York City, having an organized plan for the metropolis is a must. That’s where Best Movers NYC comes to the scene, guiding you through the dining options you absolutely cannot pass on!

Staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss: Exploring the thin, crispy delight of New York-style pizza

New York-style pizza is famous for its thin, hand-tossed crust. It often comes in large, foldable slices. This pizza style evolved in the early 1900s in the United States from the Neapolitan-style pizza of Italy. Since then, it has since become a dominant choice in New York and New Jersey, with regional variations across the United States. New York-style pizza’s journey to the Big Apple is a combination of waves of Italian immigrants who brought their traditional Neapolitan pizza to the city. The first pizzeria in the United States is Lombardi’s. It was founded in New York City’s Little Italy in 1905 by Gennaro Lombardi, a Neapolitan immigrant. Initially a grocery store, Lombardi’s became a pizzeria and quickly gained popularity. Furthermore, its affordable slices catered to the diverse economic capabilities of the local community.

For those seeking to experience this iconic dish, the best places you can find it at are:

  • Lombardi’s in Little Italy: As the first pizzeria in the U.S., Lombardi’s holds a special place in pizza history.
  • Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn: Established in 1965 by Domenico DeMarco, it’s a must-visit for authentic New York-style pizza.
  • Lucali in Carroll Gardens: Known for its long wait times and frequent appearances on best pizza lists, Lucali has been a beloved spot since 2006.
  • L&B Spumoni Gardens in Gravesend: Famous for its square slices and the unique experience of enjoying pizza al fresco.
  • Joe’s Pizza in West Village: It represents the quintessential New York slice–large, foldable, and rich in flavor.
pizza as one of the staples of nyc you can't miss
Savor the legendary New York-style pizza

Why is it popular among many?

The charm of New York-style pizza lies in its simplicity and adaptability. Its thin, pliable crust makes it easy to fold and eat on the go. The traditional tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese toppings create a perfect balance of flavors. What’s more, they can be augmented with various additional toppings to suit any taste. This pizza has become a symbol of New York’s rich culture. Furthermore, it embodies the city’s dynamic spirit and its ability to blend tradition with innovation.

For newcomers and residents alike, exploring these famous spots offers a taste of delicious pizza and a slice of New York’s history and culture. Whether you’re moving to the city or just visiting, local moving companies NYC has a number of can facilitate a smooth transition, allowing you more time to indulge in these culinary delights.

The New York bagel: A delicious symbol of cultural fusion

Originating from Poland, the first bagel is said to have been made in honor of King John Sobieski III of Poland after his victory in the 1683 Battle of Vienna. This creation, initially named ‘beugel‘ (Austrian for stirrup), symbolized the king’s stirrup. Furthermore, it commemorates his victory and the liberation that allowed Jewish people to bake bread products like bagels. Bagels came to New York with Eastern European Jewish immigrants in the late 1800s. Initially produced in small bakeries, they were hand-rolled, boiled, and baked. As these immigrants assimilated into different parts of the city, they shared their culinary traditions, and by the 1960s, bagels became a significant part of New York’s food scene, thanks to innovations in packaging and distribution. The 1980s saw the bagel evolve in size, making the New York Bagel a distinct culinary icon.

  • Ess-a-Bagel in Midtown: Since 1976, Ess-a-Bagel has been a beloved Manhattan staple. Their menu offers a range of cream cheese options and special sandwiches, satisfying diverse palates across the five boroughs.
  • Russ & Daughters on the Lower East Side: Their Orchard Street café and Brooklyn factory are a testament to their enduring popularity.
bagles in a bowl
Indulge in a classic New York bagel, one of the true staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss.

Why do New York bagels stand out?

The enduring question is why New York bagels are superior. Some attribute it to the city’s water, which has an ideal calcium-to-magnesium ratio. This results in a chewy texture that’s hard to replicate. Additionally, New York bagel shops have perfected the process by refrigerating the dough before rolling (enhancing flavor). Also, boiling the bagel in a water and baking soda mixture creates a shiny, crisp outside and a soft inside. For those moving to New York or just visiting, exploring these renowned bagel spots offers a taste of the city’s rich history and cultural amalgamation. The best moving companies Brooklyn locals trust can help newcomers settle in, helping them enjoy these culinary delights that are a staple of New York’s identity sooner rather than later.

Pastrami on rye is another one of the staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss

Pastrami on rye is a quintessential New York City sandwich. It is deeply rooted in the city’s Jewish deli tradition. This iconic sandwich was first created in 1888 by Sussman Volk, a Lithuanian immigrant. He began serving it at his deli on Delancey Street, only for it to become a favorite among the Jewish population soon. Volk’s introduction of the sandwich came after he received a pastrami recipe from a Romanian immigrant friend. This exchange led to the creation of a delicacy that would become a New York staple.

Nowadays, pastrami on rye is something you can find at:

  • Katz’s Delicatessen (Lower East Side, Manhattan): Katz’s is perhaps the most famous destination for pastrami on rye. The sandwich here is known for its generous serving of pastrami, making it a challenge to take a reasonable bite out of.
  • Essen NY Deli (Midwood): Pastrami lovers flock to Essen NY Deli for its classic sandwich version, featuring thinly sliced pastrami between soft rye bread, accompanied by pickles and cole slaw.

    sandwiches as one of the staples of nyc cuisine you can't miss
    Dive into the world of deli sandwiches, particularly the pastrami on rye

The appeal of pastrami on rye lies in its perfect blend of flavors and textures: the spicy, smoky pastrami combined with the crispness of rye bread and the zing of mustard creates a memorable eating experience. Furthermore, it’s a sandwich that tells a story of cultural fusion, tradition, and culinary craftsmanship. For those relocating to Manhattan, indulging in pastrami on rye sandwiches is a must, if not on a daily basis. And for a smooth move, seeking the best movers Manhattan services can ensure you have plenty of time to enjoy this and other culinary delights the city offers.

The quintessential New York hot dog

The hot dog owes its origins to German immigrants who introduced “dachshund sausages” in the 1860s. Charles Feltman opened the first hot dog stand on Coney Island in 1871. Over the years, hot dogs became more than just a quick bite; they assimilated into American life, particularly on the streets and boardwalks of New York City. The introduction of hot dog stands and carts provided New Yorkers and tourists with an affordable, convenient, and delicious food option—Feltman’s innovation of serving sausages in rolls added to their appeal and convenience.

Here are a couple of great spots to grab a hot dog when in the city:

  • Nathan’s Famous (Coney Island): Established in 1916 by Nathan Handwerker, a Polish immigrant, Nathan’s Famous is a historic landmark in Brooklyn, known for its juicy hot dogs with a tight casing.
  • Gray’s Papaya (Upper West Side): Founded in 1973 by Nicholas Gray, Gray’s Papaya is famous for its crispy-skinned all-beef Sabretts. This mini-chain has been a popular spot for both hot dogs and tropical drinks.
hot dogs as staples of nyc cuisine you can't miss
Experience the authentic street food flavor with a New York hot dog

Why do people love hot dogs in New York?

New York hot dogs are famous for their simplicity, flavor, and affordability. They represent a quick, satisfying meal that fits the city’s fast-paced lifestyle. Whether enjoyed from a street cart or at a sit-down venue like Gray’s Papaya, they offer a quintessential New York experience. The combination of juicy sausage, a soft bun, and classic condiments like mustard, ketchup, sauerkraut, or onions makes each hot dog a delightful treat. Trying a classic New York hot dog is a must for those moving to New York City. Residential movers NYC residents speak highly of can help with the logistics of your move, giving you ample time to explore these culinary landmarks.

Sweet staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss

New York-style cheesecake is a beloved dessert in the city. Arnold Reuben was a creator of this style in the 1920s. His experiment with a cheese pie using cream cheese, a product originally from New York, led to the birth of this now-iconic dessert. By the 1920s, New York-style cheesecake had gained immense popularity. The foundation for it was laid when cream cheese was accidentally created by a New York dairy farmer in 1872. This happy accident changed the cheesecake landscape forever. Leo “Lindy” Lindemann and his wife Clara further popularized this treat in NYC. In 1921, they opened a deli in Manhattan’s Theater District featuring a creamy cheesecake topped with strawberries.

a pieces of cheesecake
Explore the sweet side of the city

As for the top places to try this beloved dessert, we recommend visiting:

  • Junior’s (Brooklyn and Times Square): Founded by Harry Rosen in 1950, Junior’s has become synonymous with New York-style cheesecake. Rosen, who initially opened a luncheonette in 1929, transitioned to Junior’s Restaurant post-World War II. In the 1960s, Junior’s perfected its cheesecake recipe, becoming a cultural and culinary landmark where people from all walks of life gather.
  • Harry Rosen’s Downtown Brooklyn mainstay: This location is renowned for its classic New York-style cheesecake made with Philadelphia cream cheese and a sponge cake base, baked by hand to this day.

The popularity of cheesecakes

New York-style cheesecake is popular for its simplicity and elegance. The combination of creamy, rich cheese with a subtle sweetness and dense texture makes it a delightful treat, especially following an exciting yet tiring move with Midtown movers. Its versatility allows for various toppings and flavors. Whether enjoyed in a Brooklyn diner or a cozy Manhattan café, each slice offers a taste of New York’s rich culinary heritage that is hard to pass on.

Manhattan: A Chinese culinary hub

Chinese restaurants have been a part of New York City’s culinary scene since the 1860s. Chinatown’s early eateries were modest tea houses and rice shops, primarily serving immigrants. However, by the 1890s, more substantial establishments appeared on Mott and Pell streets, attracting both Chinese and non-Chinese patrons. By the turn of the century, Chinese restaurants had spread uptown, integrating into the broader New York dining landscape. Chinatown’s cuisine gained popularity among New Yorkers for its exotic flavors and unique dining experience. Places like the Port Arthur Restaurant, which opened in 1897, became magnets for adventurous diners. Nowadays, those settling in post-moving with Chinatown movers, along with those who have long resided in the area, all gladly come to these establishments for a sensory journey through China’s authentic dishes.

chinese food
Try the ethnic flavors of NYC with a serving of delicious dim sum from one of Chinatown’s eateries.

Discover these unmissable staples of NYC cuisine

Let’s not forget that New York City’s culinary scene is an adventure waiting to be explored. Each bite of these iconic dishes is a testament to the city’s rich cultural legacy. It doesn’t matter if this is your first visit or your hundredth; the staples of NYC cuisine you can’t miss provide an experience that continually evolves, surprises, and delights. So, arm yourself with a sense of culinary curiosity and dive into the flavors that make New York City a food lover’s paradise. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you!

Latest Posts