NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get

Navigating the housing market in the City That Never Sleeps can be an intimidating task. It will be an additional thing that you will have to worry about during a move if you decide to handle it on your own at least. Yet, with guidance from the best moving companies New York City offers, uncovering the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get transforms from a challenge to an adventure. Let’s dive into these intriguing areas.

Sunset Park, Brooklyn

Sunset Park is a hidden gem in Brooklyn, known for its rich architectural history and a skyline shaped by different eras. It’s a place where the past meets the present, offering a break from the hectic pace of modern life. Although not yet a trendy spot, it is gaining popularity among millennials and artists who appreciate its affordable home prices, which average around $586,000.

More and more people are moving to this area, attracted by its unique charm and the relatively low cost of living compared to other parts of the city. Therefore, acquiring housing here isn’t as easy as it might be in other neighborhoods in the borough. Nevertheless, if you manage to secure a place for yourself, you can rely on the movers Sunset Park has to offer to help you settle without a hitch.

Picture of a river
This neighborhood is surprisingly affordable for being part of NYC.

Riverdale, Bronx

Riverdale in the Bronx offers a unique and calm suburban feel, different from the usual city life. It is known for its large homes surrounded by green spaces, providing a peaceful environment. This area has a strong sense of community, helping people build long-lasting relationships. Yet, finding a home here is not simple due to the limited availability of properties. The average price of a home, being $377,000, also results in high demand that movers Riverdale NY provides have witnessed firsthand due to their higher-than-average booking rates.

Fort Greene, Brooklyn

Following Riverdale, we land in Fort Greene, a neighborhood that has freshly welcomed over a thousand new housing units. Despite this considerable addition, the demand graph spirals upwards unabated, portraying the area’s popularity. Interestingly, statistics uncovered by movers Fort Greene residents have been steadily turning to reveal an unwavering preference for the neighborhoods. But seizing a place here isn’t devoid of challenges. The high price of $1.119 million is the first obstacle for many. The availability remains limited, nudging potential residents to enter the housing market with well-strategized plans.

Exploring Jamaica in Queens – one of the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get

In Queens, we come upon Jamaica, a neighborhood that ushered in 1,047 new housing units in 2022 alone. The buzz surrounding this area has skyrocketed, making it a focal point for potential homeowners. Additionally, the neighborhood showcases a mix of cultures, adding to its increasing allure. However, this surge has initiated a high demand for reasonably priced homes of $618,000. Hence, having a proficient team by your side, such as the reputed moving companies Jamaica NY offers, can significantly ease your transition into this booming locality. Should you manage to secure the unit, that is.

Picture of a train station that is located in Jamaica NYC
Many nationalities call this neighborhood home.

Moving to Elmhurst in Queens is a trend in 2023

Elmhurst stands as another rising star in Queens tipped to be one of the potential hot neighborhoods for 2023. The district manifests a robust potential for growth, forecasting a steep curve in demand, thanks to the low average price of $475,000. Here, engaging with trusted Elmhurst moving companies and real estate agents becomes essential in navigating the promising yet competitive housing landscape.

Woodside, Queens

Woodside, Queens, is quickly gaining popularity. This area is full of cultures and promises modern conveniences, attracting more and more people. The average house price stands at $443,000, although there’s quite a limited number of properties available. This neighborhood is full of life, as proven by its diverse demographic data. If you’re considering a move here, brace yourself for stiff competition. But don’t fret! Teaming up with the adept movers Woodside NY has to offer can add a dash of fun and expertise to your moving adventure and allow you more time to find a home for yourself here.

Marble Hill, Manhattan

Moving from Queens to Marble Hill in Manhattan means stepping into a place that is full of history but doesn’t lack modern amenities either. Right now, finding a home in the neighborhood is like looking for a needle in a haystack, with fewer than ten properties up for sale. This is due to a mix of its terrific location and tight-knit community, which has led to high prices and limited choices.

Chinatown, Manhattan

Looking at Manhattan’s Chinatown, it’s clear why this place is highly desirable. The streets are lively, and the food is authentic, making it a favorite spot for both locals and tourists. Over time, it has blended old traditions with new energy, offering a one-of-a-kind lifestyle. Buying a home here won’t be simple, as many are trying to do the same. The average house price is near the city’s mean, making it more accessible compared to other popular areas.

Picture of a street in one of the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get
Chinatown is one of the most popular neighborhoods in NYC

West Village, Manhattan

Following Chinatown, we have West Village, a historic heart in Manhattan, promising a serene yet unique lifestyle. The area has become a focal point for potential homeowners in recent years, partly due to its cobblestone streets and pre-war buildings, which bring a distinct character to the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get. But what makes this neighborhood so sought-after that finding a place to live is almost impossible? Well, it’s the promise of tranquility in the middle of the city. Due to its popularity and central location, it takes a staggering $1.6 million to land a property here—a sum, you’d agree, not many can afford to pay.

Greenwich Village, Manhattan

Next, we turn to Greenwich Village, traditionally known as an artists’ sanctuary. Its rich history as a hub for artists and thinkers has crafted a locale bursting with creativity and intellectual richness. Statistically, it has hosted numerous artists and intellectuals since the early 20th century, fostering a community that cherishes art and culture. The areal real estate landscape is as diverse as its cultural background. It offers various housing options ranging from historic brownstones to modern apartments. Besides, potential residents are advised to engage with seasoned real estate agents to find the perfect home that aligns with their aesthetic, lifestyle preferences, and budget. The average home here costs $1.6 million, and options are pretty limited.

Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn

Diving into Downtown Brooklyn is like exploring the heart of business and culture in NYC. This area showcases the city’s ongoing growth, blending the business world with cultural scenes. In recent years, the arrival of big companies has breathed new life into Downtown Brooklyn, creating a dynamic and promising commercial environment. Although one that comes with a steep price and not nearly enough housing options. The same is true of the commercial spaces, which happen to be fewer with each passing day.

Picture of Downtown Brooklyn, one of the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get
In recent years, many corporations have settled in Downtown Brooklyn.

Upper Carnegie Hill, Manhattan

Moving to Upper Carnegie Hill in Manhattan, you’ll find a quiet and elegant area. This place is known for the Carnegie Hill Historic District, where beautiful old buildings meet famous landmarks. Its calm setting and closeness to Central Park make it a perfect home for people wanting peaceful living that is still well-connected. This neighborhood has become a sort of gem in NYC, known for being stylish and modern. It has a blend of classy and new features that many find very appealing, hence the limited availability of livable spaces.

Astoria, Queens, is another one of the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get

Astoria, Queens, with its commendable Greek presence, is one of the most diverse places in the Big Apple. The place is a food lover’s dream, with restaurants like Trattoria L’incontro offering dishes from all over the world. While the neighborhood boasts a dynamic blend of old and new, with family-owned shops and modern boutiques close by, it also has a growing real estate market. People are increasingly interested in it, drawn by its beautiful streets filled with historical buildings and the relatively affordable average home price of $670,000 and average rent of $3,600. The easy commute to Manhattan and the arts and entertainment options add to its appeal. The neighborhood hasn’t yet finished developing, and as it continues to do so, it’s slowly but surely becoming more and more desirable, resulting in fewer properties than actually needed.

Navigating NYC’s unique neighborhoods during your move

In the face of NYC’s dynamic and ever-changing landscape, one cannot overlook the unique characteristics that govern each neighborhood.

  • A critical aspect to remember is the varied parking regulations that dictate the streets of neighborhoods such as Astoria or Upper Carnegie Hill; being aware of alternate parking rules can save new residents from unnecessary fines.
  • Furthermore, when considering rapidly growing neighborhoods like Downtown Brooklyn, staying ahead in the rental or buying market is vital. Here, properties tend to get snapped up quickly.
  • Engaging with local communities through neighborhood forums or social media groups can offer invaluable insights and help you settle in more smoothly.
  • Those moving to historic neighborhoods should be prepared for potential housing codes and preservation guidelines. It’s common to find stricter regulations surrounding renovations or alterations in such places.
  • Lastly, embracing the neighborhood’s culture by frequenting local businesses and eateries and partaking in community events can be a rewarding way to foster connections and truly become a part of these NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get.
Picture of a compass
Moving to one of the NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get requires preparation.

Ready to attempt venturing into NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get?

NYC neighborhoods that play hard to get aren’t just being coy. They’re either packed to the brim or priced sky-high. Looking for a spot in these areas? Good luck! They’re the city’s hottest tickets. So, if you’re eyeing these places, be ready for a challenge. But hey, who doesn’t love a good NYC hustle? Dive in if you dare!



Sunset Park New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Riverdale New York NY Home Prices & home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Fort Greene New York NY Home Prices & home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Jamaica New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Elmhurst New York NY Home Prices & home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Woodside New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

West Village New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Greenwich Village New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Astoria New York NY Home Prices & Home Values | Zillow. (n.d.). Zillow.

Latest Posts